RSS Updates

09

Mar

18

Twitter Loses Funding, Announces Closure

twitter

Twitter announced today that it was unable secure investment in its latest round of funding and that it will close within 6 weeks if a buyer isn’t found.

Okay, so not really but it is going to happen and when it does Evan Williams and Biz Stone are going to be kicking themselves for not selling to Facebook for a cool 500 mill last year.

The Real Reason That Twitter Can’t Make Money

Twitter is an application and business model fundamentally flawed on so many levels that it makes the head spin. There are ways out of it but if they haven’t figured it out by now it’s obvious they aren’t going to and the longer they leave it the less interested anyone will be to buy a failed business model. Google recognise this and say they aren’t up for buying it and yet they bought YouTube in a heartbeat. So what went wrong?

YOU CAN’T MONETISE THE STREAM

And that’s all it is. Let’s analyse why Google isn’t interested…….

Okay, it doesn’t take much analysing, just a bit of common sense which Ev Williams and crew have thrown out the window apparently. Why did Google buy YouTube? Why do they provide a free email service to millions? Because people spend alot of time on those websites. And when people come to your site guess what you can do? Advertise! It’s all the rage apparently but Twitter didn’t catch on. Instead they provide an API free of charge so that people can spend no time on their site. Yep, they just give away all their traffic because apparently it isn’t worth anything.

But 4 million people visited Twitter last month!

I “use” Twitter but the only time I go to twitter.com is to spam…sorry, follow other people. And that is what those millions of people are doing because, let’s face, there’s nothing to see at twitter.com (link nofollow’d of course). And when you’re trying to follow 100 people in one sitting the mouse is in a clicking frenzy with up to 20 open browser tabs. I’m in the zone but sure, whack some some ads in on those pages, I’m sure I’ll click on one.

Twitter is streamed to me via TweetDeck. The only way Twitter can monetise the stream is to release a TweetDeck type application and drop their API, forcing all users to use their app which they can monetise all they want. But part of Twitter’s success is that internet geeks can make totally worthless apps that will never get used so if they drop the API and force people to use their own app I think many people would just stop using it.

How about all those Tweets that get sent out via SMS? Surely someone with an iota of business acumen would see the opportunity and mark up the cost but nopes, that is money they don’t need.

The latest buzz is adwords type ads on Twitter’s search page. Because all of a sudden we are hearing from everywhere that Twitter’s search function is almost better and more relevant than Google.

Riiiiiiiiiiiiight.

Twitter’s search of user’s inane tweets about what they are reading currently and what they had for dinner is waaay better than Google with all that content in 140 characters? I bet Eric Schmidt is shaking in his
boots.

The Many (ahem) Uses of Twitter

So what is Twitter and what is it not?

It’s a vehicle to get your word out, instant messaging to the masses. And if you follow thousands of people that is thousands of people with something to say. The horror. The blogging phenonemon is bad enough as it suddenly gave people with no technical knowledge an easy platform to voice anything that came to mind. But now you don’t even have to format an article.

Twitter is not a network and it’s not a community. For the most part (the part that creates all the hype) it’s a collection of people that follow people so they get followed back so they can spam links and maybe get traffic. Forums *can be* communities if the member base is not posting just to drive traffic to their sites like DigitalPoint or WebHostingTalk. And bloggers, sorry, but your blog is not a community either as we all know most commenters comment for one reason only.

The only people that maybe get real value are high profile names that ordinary folks have a genuine interest in and follow. And if the person they follow isn’t following 10,000 people. Like high profile bloggers/IMers/SEOers like Sugarrae (follows a handful, has 5000 following). Fair play and all that but they are the ones hyping Twitter. But that isn’t a network. It’s more like a Facebook fan page and for that Facebook is better. And it matters not that Facebook grows a twitter every 10 days, Twitter will still make FB redundant (in 2087). Twitter is useful for the person that has many followers but doesn’t follow people as they can get real time feedback and also when they need to get word out they can (as long as his/her followers aren’t following 10,000 people). I often hear about “real-time conversations” but I don’t see that. We aren’t all following the same people so conversation are one sided. Someone I’m following is replying to someone I don’t even know. This is not a network. Twitter is a free-for-all link spam medium.

The problem with Twitter can be summed up with this post. To sum up it’s all about ME, ME, ME and furthering my interests whether it be spamming my content (points 1, 4, and 5) or trying to needle my way into meeting someone to further my ambitions (points 2 and 3) and being blatantly obnoxious (8, 9, 10).

I joined Twitter because I’m into SEO and IM and Blogging and everywhere I went people were telling me to “Follow” them and that if I wasn’t on Twitter I would be missing oput on the next thing since sliced bread. So I got on there and played around, followed loads of people in the field I was interested in. And the result? A stream of spam of links to crap articles and Guy Kawasaki posting AllTop headlines every 3 minutes? Seriously, DoubleYou Tee Eff? And being the good sheep I am I tried it myself but I am just far to cynical and self-aware to do something that when I saw others doing I thought “but you’re only on Twitter and posting that link so I can come read some crap you wrote”.

Buy hey, maybe I don’t “get” Twitter but then again I’m not an egocentric, self-interested marketer whose sole goal is to get the word out. I have a business, I have products to sell, the company has a client base and a blog, forum and mail lists are all I need to “connect” to our user base. I hate self-promotion. I’d much rather leave it up to users to get the word out about our service. And if you provide a decent service that can be all you need (not including real advertising). But maybe i’m not alone because Eric Schmidt also doesn’t get it but who is he anyway?

The True Power Of Twitter

Many will say that the power of Twitter is that something can quickly go viral. Well, can it? I’d like to see some stats to back up something that went truly viral on Twitter. But all that traffic from Twitter is listed as Direct Traffic (unless you put some tracking on a link). But this is another problem. People maybe retweet a link instead of referencing it in a post or article. Hey, thanks, I apprciate the RT but I’d rather have the link thanks. John Andrews writes about how Twitter is changing our linking behaviour and does it alot more eloquently than I could ever do. Maybe the best thing that could happen is someone finds a post via Twitter and then Diggs it from where it can go truly viral. But then again no-one is really reading the stream anyway. So Twitter isn’t replacing the web, isn’t replacing Google and it isn’t a search engine.

Twitter’s growth is far from steady, in fact Twitter could be peaking. The hype will die down and all the people that got drawn in to Twitter with promises of making millions will leave when they come to the realisation, “What the hell am I doing? I could have just written 3 articles and built 100 links but instead I spent 5 hours retweeting nonsense and spamming a link to a blog post I wrote last week and got 5 visits”.

Somewhat of a rant but when the places you love like TechCrunch and Search Engine Journal fill your mail daily with a Twitter article every third post something somewhere is going to crack.

So lets get off Twitter, get to writing and get back to real linking. See all those links in this post, that is what we should be doing.

But do follow me on Twitter. I probably don’t know you but I can’t wait to here about what you’re reading and how you slept last night. ;)

(My fire-retardent suit is on and if you read all that I won’t hold it against you for flaming me)

The HostNexus Blog covers company announcements and system updates as well as general ramblings about Web Development, SEO, Design, Hosting and anything of interest to our clients and readers.

13 Responses to “Twitter Loses Funding, Announces Closure”

  1. Andrea Tannouri

    March 18th

    Hmmmm are you being sarcastic here? I don’t know that I agree with you about Twitter – it has changed my thinking radically and I love love love it b/c of the lovely people I interact with and get support from. It’s undeniable that my Twitter account is an advertising platform as well about all the things I care about, but it’s not spam b/c people choose to follow me. They can tune me out or unfollow me at any time if they feel I’m spammy.

    I’m a newer Twitter user but I’ve made close friends here in a few short months. I definitely feel it is a unique community…

    =) @AndreaTannouri the @HolisticMamma =) and raging Twitterholic =)

    Andrea Tannouri’s last blog post..Lisa Donner and rawveganhippie are now friends

  2. Hey, I follow ya. :mrgreen:

    I don’t follow anyone, I make sure their interests mirror mine.

    I’ve been following Twitter since 2007 but only recently started to get involved. I wish I got the feeling off Twitter that you did. I just hate that it’s a marketing platform – or feels like it is for me at the moment. To behonest I think I need to use it like Facebook. FB for me is a place where I interact with all my old friends from back home 20 years ago – we all have a connection. I don’t feel that connection with Twitter. If I left the marketing model behind and followed people with the same non-marketing interests I think I would get alot out of it.

    But then I wouldn’t be using it in the way that many say it should be used and I must admit I jumped on the marketing bandwagon and not the pursuit of peace, harmony and happiness (which is where i think I could learn alot from people).

    Hmmm, maybe I just solved my Twitter issues…..

  3. Cindy C.

    March 18th

    I guess I look at it as a microcosm of life. I don’t follow everyone myself. But, I do follow people who have interests dissimilar to my own. IRL I have many friends who do not mirror my interests. If one only follows people with exact same interests, where’s the growth? I would say that my problem is totally opposite of yours. I have a hard time even mentioning my business, so as not to make it all about me, me, me. lol Perhaps we should team twitter. JK

  4. Robin

    March 19th

    It will be interesting to see how this plays out.

    One approach they could take would be to look at the more popular popular platforms that use the API and incorporate those features with an advertising piece.

    They could outperform tweetdeck for example, and make slight tweaks in the API to push people over to the ad-supported in house version.

  5. Vladimir

    March 25th

    Dear Sir, allow me to inform you that I have made a great many friends of my own persuasion on twitter. Some of us are not motivated purely by greed, avarice and lust (although I may veer toward the last-mentioned on occasions especially when it comes to fresh sardine oil)and my involvement on twitter is to merely befriend.

    To this end my blog readers have increased and donations to my own worthy causes have soared.

    This may be small peanuts to some, but big brazils to me.

    yours respectfully,
    Vladimir Ilyich
    http://twitter.com/VladimirCat

    Vladimir’s last blog post..A Couch is not a Home

  6. Thanks for all your comments. It’s great to see that Twitter is a positive experience for so many.

  7. mr. meeble

    April 2nd

    thanks for the interesting article – I actually agree with you mostly. I have been thinking similar thoughts, I just wasn’t able to articulate it as well as you. only time will tell…

    mr. meeble’s last blog post..thoughts on twitter

  8. Jon Boyd

    April 3rd

    From the title I thought is was an April fool’s joke.

    Like you I’ve been told by business friends that I should investigate it.

    I was even planning to look into it this weekend.

    Now I think I’ll put it off a little longer.

    It also seems that so much of what I deal with at work is confidential, (We help people buy homes and the negotiations involved can run into tens of thousands of dollars. Posting information about my routine could have a significant impact on those outcomes.)

    I hardly know what I would post about other than maybe SEO work.

    Thanks for the alternative view.

  9. @mr. meeble – nice blog post and thaks for the link!

    @Jon – thanks for the comment. I read another interesting article the other day that also bashes Guy Kawasaki and his tactics (I just gave him one line though):

    Is Guy Kawasaki Singlehandedly Ruining Twitter

    Funny thing is the author of the post is in the industry that abuses Twitter the most.

  10. @jay_diggity

    April 22nd

    Twitter could monetize very easily. They could charge $50 per year for a premium account. Which is anything over 1,000 followers. They could figure out a way to monetize the search function. Twitter is now one of the biggest market research.

  11. Sean Meyer

    February 15th

    damn that was intense. I agree with most of what you said, but I still feel Twitter is a very powerful tool. 70% of Twitter is ME ME ME, but what about the people that are YOU YOU YOU. It is when you genuinely are posting, to educate or even entertain your audience that it becomes an amazing source of information.
    .-= Sean Meyer´s last blog ..HardcoreCanada: The chances of having the birthday on the same day as your partner is 1/730 not that crazy. But I have never met one. /discuss #fb #sobobo =-.

  12. Hope Full!

    April 15th

    Umm, people.. you know by now that the “people” you follow are very likely not who they claim?? so, you’ve been reading Tweets from major business people huh? not stay-at-home Tweet spammers? hey don’t knock my short-lived addition to Paris Hilton’s Tweet log! I’m so totally sure she’s personally cracking wise like, that’s hot man.. it’s a fantasy, not a harmful one but sorta sad. The only business model is for the marketing people writing the Tweets.

  13. Jimbo

    April 18th

    For sure a lot of internet marketers work with Twitter, Facebook and other social media. But you can ignore them, don’t add them as friends and that’s all. Totally agree with the author, Twitter is more like a facebook fan page, don’t like it


Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge
  Find out how to get an image with your comment.