Woo has some nice stuff.
I would forget the Elegant Themes - but that's a personal preference of mine. I expect at least an outward show of support when I buy a theme from some place that promises support
I gave up searching for a good premium theme - for premium, read paid. Some of the themes I've seen for sale wouldn't pass muster in primary school.
I've ended up making my own .. as in
Cafe Porridge I got by with a lot of intensive reading at
http://www.themelab.com/ where Leland gives clear and practical tutes.
It depends what you want the theme for, how you will use it. I suppose you're after a magazine style? A couple here at
http://www.premiumwp.com/best-news-a...theme-gallery/